Principles

  • Openness. Every company in the industry can become a member, and everyone can comment on proposals during the public comment period.
  • Transparency. Proposals, comments, decisions and their reasons are documented and published.
  • Balance. Brands, retail, solution providers and associations are represented. No company holds more than one third of the seats on the board.
  • Consensus. Decisions are sought by consensus. A vote is the exception, not the rule.
  • Voluntary use. Using the standard is voluntary, and the specification is free for everyone.

Who decides what

Working groups
Prepare and decide on the content of the specification: fields, requirement levels, code values, examples and category profiles. Each working group has a chair who runs its meetings and an editor who maintains its parts of the specification.
Board
Sets up working groups, approves new versions of the specification for release, decides on appeals and on questions that concern more than one working group.
Members
Take part in the working groups and vote there. Members decide which category profiles come next.
The public
Comments on every proposal during the public comment period.

Consensus

A working group has reached consensus when no member of the group maintains a reasoned objection. An objection is reasoned when it names the problem and, where possible, a way to solve it. The chair establishes whether consensus has been reached and records it in the minutes.

Consensus does not mean that everyone agrees with everything. It means that the concerns raised have been heard and weighed, and that no one sees a reason serious enough to block the proposal.

Votes

If consensus cannot be reached, the chair can call a vote. Each member company has one vote in a working group, regardless of how many people it sends. Quorum and majorities are set out in the statutes and the rules of procedure of the organisation. The result of every vote and the reasons of the minority, if they wish, are recorded in the minutes.

From proposal to release

  1. Proposal. Anyone can propose a change. A proposal describes the problem, the change and its effect on existing records.
  2. Public comment. Every proposal is published for public comment for at least 30 days.
  3. Disposition of comments. The working group answers every comment: accepted, accepted with changes, or not accepted, with a reason. The answers are published.
  4. Decision. The working group decides by consensus or, if needed, by vote.
  5. Release. The board approves the release. Accepted changes appear in a new version of the specification and in the changelog, following the versioning rules.

An overview of the steps is shown under how the standard changes.

Records

  • Every meeting has an agenda sent in advance and minutes sent afterwards.
  • Minutes record the participants, the topics, the decisions and the reasons for them. They are available to all members.
  • Every change to the specification is listed in the changelog with its reason.

Appeals

A member who believes that a decision was made without following these rules can appeal to the board in writing within 30 days of the decision being published. The appeal names the decision and the rule that was not followed. The board answers in writing with reasons. Members of the board who were involved in the decision do not take part in deciding the appeal.

All meetings follow the antitrust guideline and the code of conduct. People with a personal interest in a decision follow the rules on conflicts of interest.

Questions: hello@openjuvenile.org.

Last updated: October 2026